Cold email teardown and rewrite for a pitch getting no replies
Takes a cold email that is not getting replies, scores it line by line for relevance, length, clarity of the ask and signs of a template, then returns two rewritten versions with the reason for every change. Use it when an outreach campaign has low reply rates and the team cannot tell whether the list, the offer or the writing is the problem.
The output this prompt produced, unedited.
The prompt
Constraints first
The rewrite stays under 100 words, with one question as the ask.
The first line is about the prospect, never about the sender.
No claims, numbers or client names that are not in the inputs.
Spam-trigger phrasing such as "quick question", "just checking in" or all-caps words is removed.
Inputs
The current email, subject line included: [paste]
Who it goes to: [e.g. operations heads at logistics firms with 50 to 500 staff]
What is offered: [e.g. route planning software that cuts fuel cost]
Results so far: [e.g. 600 sent, 48% opened, 0.5% replied]
Proof available: [e.g. one case study with a named client, or none]
Teardown
Score each line from 1 to 5 for whether the prospect would care.
Mark lines that sound like a template sent to everyone.
Check that the problem named is one this role really has.
Check that the ask is small and easy to say yes to.
Say whether the results point to the list, the subject line or the body.
Output format
| Line | Score | Problem | Fix |
Diagnosis in three sentences.
Rewrite A: problem-led. Rewrite B: observation-led, with a [personal detail] slot.
Three subject lines under six words.
A note on what to test first and how many sends it needs.
Copy the prompt and paste it into Gemini, then set the aspect ratio to 3:4. No reference photo is needed for this one.
The prompt is written in Markdown with each part under its own heading, which is what the copy action hands over. Change one section at a time, keeping the rest intact, so you can tell which change did the work.