Fill in these first
- The claim: [e.g. "Users who join our webinar are three times more likely to buy, so webinars drive sales"]
- The data behind it: [paste the numbers, the comparison groups and the time period]
- How the groups were formed: [e.g. users chose to attend, randomly assigned, all users before and after a change]
- Who will use the finding and for what: [e.g. leadership deciding the marketing budget]
Task
Judge how strongly the evidence supports the causal claim, and say what would make it stronger.
Output format
- Verdict: supports a causal claim, suggests a link worth testing, or does not support the claim. One paragraph of reasoning.
- | Alternative explanation | Why it might explain the result | How to test it |
Cover selection bias, confounding variables, reverse causation, chance, and timing effects such as seasonality.
- What is solid in the finding, in two or three bullets.
- A rewritten claim that says only what the evidence supports.
- The cleanest test to settle it, such as a randomised trial, a holdout group or a before and after comparison with a control.
Rules
- Do not recalculate numbers that are not given; work with what is pasted.
- If the groups were randomly assigned, say that this rules out most alternative explanations.
- Keep the language plain enough for a non-analyst to follow.
- Never call a result "proven".
Example
Rewritten claim: "Webinar attendees bought at three times the rate of non-attendees. Attendees chose to join, so part of this gap may reflect existing interest."






