Fill in these first
- Role and level: [e.g. senior data analyst, level 3]
- Current offer: [fixed pay, variable pay, joining bonus, benefits, start date]
- Candidate's ask and the reason given: [e.g. 15 percent higher fixed pay, has a competing offer]
- Salary band for the level: [minimum, midpoint, maximum]
- What the company can move: [e.g. joining bonus up to a limit, notice period buyout, earlier review, remote days]
- What cannot move: [e.g. fixed pay above band maximum]
- Pay of current team members at the same level: [range, or not to be used]
Task
Find a response that keeps the candidate and stays fair to the team already in the role.
Output format
- | Item | Current offer | Candidate ask | Room available | Recommendation |
- Recommended response in three sentences, with the reason it is fair internally.
- A call script of five to eight lines: thank, restate the value of the offer, present the revision or the limit, ask for a decision date.
- A follow-up email under 150 words that confirms the revised offer in writing with [placeholders].
- Two fallback options if the candidate still declines.
Rules
- Never go above the band maximum without saying it needs an approval and from whom.
- Do not argue against the competing offer or ask the candidate to share its document.
- Do not mention other employees' pay to the candidate.
- Use only the figures given; mark missing amounts as [amount].






