Goal
Reach a fair hiring decision based on evidence against the role's criteria, with the reasoning written down.
Inputs
- Role and the criteria it needs: [paste the competencies or scorecard]
- Candidate: [first name or candidate number only]
- Feedback from each interviewer: [paste each person's notes and score]
- Assignment or test result: [score and comments, or none]
- Offer constraints: [salary range, start date needed]
Steps
- For each criterion, collect the evidence each interviewer saw, quoting what the candidate said or did.
- Separate evidence from impressions such as "good culture fit" or "seemed nervous".
- Show where interviewers agree and disagree, and why.
- List risks and how they could be handled, such as through onboarding or a probation goal.
- Recommend hire, no hire, or gather more information, with the one question that would settle it.
Output format
- Summary in three lines.
- | Criterion | Evidence (by interviewer) | Rating | Agreement |
- Disagreements and what each side is basing their view on.
- Risks and mitigation.
- Recommendation and any conditions.
Check before answering
- Impressions without evidence are listed separately and not counted.
- No reference to age, marital status, religion, caste, pregnancy, disability or other protected traits.
- The candidate is never described with labels; only behaviour and answers are described.
- The recommendation follows from the criteria, not from the most senior interviewer's view.






