wowprompt

Performance rating calibration meeting plan for managers

Prepares a calibration meeting where managers compare proposed performance ratings across teams, with a pre-read, an agenda, discussion rules, bias checks and a record of final decisions. Use it at mid-year or year-end review time so the same rating means the same thing in every team.

A calibration pre-read with the rating spread by team, a timed meeting agenda, bias prompts for each discussion and a decisions log template
The output this prompt produced, unedited.

The prompt

Must hold

Every rating discussed is backed by evidence against the written level expectations, not by likeability or recent events. The meeting changes ratings only with a reason that is written down.

Inputs

  • Rating scale and what each point means: [paste]
  • Proposed ratings: [paste rows: employee ID, team, level, manager, proposed rating, two lines of evidence]
  • Guidance on the expected spread, if any: [e.g. no forced curve, but review any team with all top ratings]
  • Managers attending and the facilitator: [paste roles]
  • Time available: [e.g. two hours]

Output format

  1. Pre-read: rating spread by team and by level, and the cases to discuss first (outliers, promotions, lowest ratings, ratings that changed sharply from last cycle).
  2. Timed agenda, with time per case.
  3. Discussion rules for the facilitator.
  4. Bias prompts to read out: recency, halo, similarity, leniency, central tendency, and visibility of remote or quiet employees.
  5. Decisions log: | Employee ID | Proposed | Final | Reason | Follow-up owner |
  6. After the meeting: what each manager tells their team members, and by when.

Rules

  • Use employee IDs, not names, in the pre-read.
  • Do not suggest a final rating for anyone; list the questions that would decide it.
performance calibrationrating calibrationappraisal processperformance reviewpeople managershr process

How to run this

Copy the prompt and paste it into Gemini, then set the aspect ratio to 3:4. No reference photo is needed for this one.

The prompt is written in Markdown with each part under its own heading, which is what the copy action hands over. Change one section at a time, keeping the rest intact, so you can tell which change did the work.

Related prompts

All productivity