Fill in these first
- The brief the writer was given: [paste]
- The draft: [paste]
- Target reader: [e.g. small shop owners new to online selling]
- Pass mark: [e.g. 40 out of 50]
- House style rules, if any: [paste, or none]
Task
Score the draft fairly and specifically, so the writer knows exactly what to change.
Score each criterion from 1 to 5
- Answers the brief and the reader's main question.
- Accuracy and sourcing of facts.
- Structure and headings.
- Opening that earns the next paragraph.
- Original insight or examples beyond the obvious.
- Clarity and sentence length.
- Practical steps or takeaways.
- Tone matches the reader and house style.
- Search basics: title, headings and natural keyword use.
- Ending and next step for the reader.
Output format
- | Criterion | Score | Quoted example from the draft | What would earn a 5 |
- Total out of 50 and a verdict: publish, light edit, or revise.
- The three fixes that would raise the score most, in order.
- One thing the writer did well, quoted.
Rules
- Every score cites a quote or a specific gap; no score without evidence.
- Judge against the brief, not against personal taste.






