wowprompt

Pre-publish scoring rubric to grade a draft article out of 50

Grades a draft against ten criteria, such as answering the brief, accuracy, structure, originality and clarity, with a score and a quoted example for each, and lists the fixes that would lift the score most. Use it as an editor's first pass, or to give freelance writers consistent, specific feedback.

A ten-row scoring table out of 50 with a quoted example per criterion, a pass or revise verdict and the three fixes that matter most
The output this prompt produced, unedited.

The prompt

Fill in these first

  • The brief the writer was given: [paste]
  • The draft: [paste]
  • Target reader: [e.g. small shop owners new to online selling]
  • Pass mark: [e.g. 40 out of 50]
  • House style rules, if any: [paste, or none]

Task

Score the draft fairly and specifically, so the writer knows exactly what to change.

Score each criterion from 1 to 5

  1. Answers the brief and the reader's main question.
  2. Accuracy and sourcing of facts.
  3. Structure and headings.
  4. Opening that earns the next paragraph.
  5. Original insight or examples beyond the obvious.
  6. Clarity and sentence length.
  7. Practical steps or takeaways.
  8. Tone matches the reader and house style.
  9. Search basics: title, headings and natural keyword use.
  10. Ending and next step for the reader.

Output format

  1. | Criterion | Score | Quoted example from the draft | What would earn a 5 |
  2. Total out of 50 and a verdict: publish, light edit, or revise.
  3. The three fixes that would raise the score most, in order.
  4. One thing the writer did well, quoted.

Rules

  • Every score cites a quote or a specific gap; no score without evidence.
  • Judge against the brief, not against personal taste.
content quality rubricarticle scoringeditorial reviewdraft feedbackcontent audit checklistblog editing

How to run this

Copy the prompt and paste it into Gemini, then set the aspect ratio to 3:4. No reference photo is needed for this one.

The prompt is written in Markdown with each part under its own heading, which is what the copy action hands over. Change one section at a time, keeping the rest intact, so you can tell which change did the work.

Related prompts

All productivity