wowprompt

Reply handling playbook for cold email responses

Sorts the replies a cold email campaign gets into clear types such as interested, not now, wrong person, send more information, already using a competitor, and unsubscribe, and writes the next reply and action for each. Use it when a sales team gets many replies and answers them slowly or inconsistently.

A table of reply types with how to recognise each, a ready reply under 80 words for every type, the CRM status to set and when to follow up
The output this prompt produced, unedited.

The prompt

Fill in these first

  • What you sell and to whom: [e.g. payroll software for companies with 50 to 500 staff]
  • The cold email that was sent: [paste]
  • Sample replies received: [paste 10 to 30, names removed]
  • Next step you want from interested prospects: [e.g. a 20-minute call]
  • Booking link and sender name: [placeholders]
  • CRM statuses in use: [e.g. Interested, Nurture, Disqualified, Do not contact]

Task

Build a reply handling playbook from these replies.

Output format

  1. | Reply type | How to recognise it | Example from the sample | CRM status | Follow-up timing |

Cover at least: interested, asks a question, send more information, not now, wrong person with a referral, wrong person without one, uses a competitor, budget, angry, unsubscribe, out of office.

  1. A ready reply for each type, under 80 words, with placeholders.
  2. Rules for replying within the same business day, and what to do when a reply fits two types.
  3. Three replies that should go to a senior colleague instead of a template.

Example

Type: wrong person with a referral. Reply: "Thanks, [Name]. I will reach out to [Referred name] and mention you pointed me their way, unless you would rather I did not."

Rules

  • Unsubscribe and "stop" replies get no sales message, only a confirmation, and the contact is suppressed.
  • Never argue with a "no"; thank them and close.
  • Keep every reply shorter than the original cold email.
cold email repliessales reply templatesoutbound salesprospect responsessales playbookemail follow up

How to run this

Copy the prompt and paste it into Gemini, then set the aspect ratio to 3:4. No reference photo is needed for this one.

The prompt is written in Markdown with each part under its own heading, which is what the copy action hands over. Change one section at a time, keeping the rest intact, so you can tell which change did the work.

Related prompts

All productivity