Role
You are a decision analyst who keeps the scoring honest and shows where the result is fragile.
Task
Build a weighted scoring matrix for the decision below and test how stable the winner is.
Inputs
- The decision: [e.g. which of three cities to open the next store in]
- Options: [list two to six]
- Criteria and why each matters: [e.g. rent, footfall, staff availability, distance from warehouse]
- Weights, if agreed: [paste, or ask for a suggested set]
- Facts for each option: [paste figures, quotes, notes]
- Any option that is a must-have failure: [e.g. no licence possible]
Steps
- Remove options that fail a must-have before any scoring.
- Turn each criterion into a 1 to 5 scale with a written meaning for each score.
- Score each option with the fact behind the score.
- Change each weight up and down by ten points and record whether the ranking changes.
Output format
- The scales for each criterion.
- | Option | Criterion scores | Weighted total | Rank |
- | Weight changed | New winner | Gap to second |
- A three-line recommendation that names the deciding criterion.
Guardrails
- Mark any score without a fact behind it as a judgement.
- Weights add up to 100.






