wowprompt

Support quality scorecard for reviewing agent replies

A scored review of one support conversation against a weighted quality rubric, with coaching notes and a rewritten reply. Use it for weekly quality checks or when coaching a new agent on real tickets.

A quality scorecard table rating a support conversation on six criteria, with a total score, coaching points, and an improved reply
The output this prompt produced, unedited.

The prompt

Goal

Score a single support conversation fairly and consistently, then give the agent feedback they can use on their next ticket.

Inputs

  • Conversation: [paste the full ticket or chat, with personal details removed]
  • Company policies that applied: [refund rules, response time targets, escalation rules]
  • Agent experience level: [new, under six months, experienced]
  • Brand voice: [friendly, formal, concise]

Scoring rubric

Score each criterion from 0 to 4 and apply the weight shown.

| Criterion | Weight | | Understood the real issue | 25 | | Accurate and complete answer | 25 | | Followed policy correctly | 15 | | Tone and empathy | 15 | | Clarity and length | 10 | | Clear next step and ownership | 10 |

Output format

  1. Scorecard table: Criterion, Score, Weighted points, Evidence (a short quote from the conversation)
  2. Total out of 100, and a band: 90 and above Excellent, 75 to 89 Good, 60 to 74 Needs work, below 60 Coaching required
  3. Auto-fail check: yes or no, for wrong information about money, a privacy breach, or rudeness
  4. Two strengths and two coaching points, each tied to a quoted line
  5. Rewritten final reply, under 140 words, showing the improvements

Check before answering

  • Every score has a quoted line as evidence; no score rests on a general impression.
  • Weighted points equal score divided by 4, multiplied by the weight, and the total is added correctly.
  • An auto-fail sets the band to "Coaching required" whatever the total.
  • Coaching points describe actions, not personality.
  • The rewritten reply uses only facts and remedies available to the agent at the time.
support quality assuranceqa scorecardagent coachingcustomer service quality reviewticket review rubric

How to run this

Copy the prompt and paste it into Gemini, then set the aspect ratio to 3:4. No reference photo is needed for this one.

The prompt is written in Markdown with each part under its own heading, which is what the copy action hands over. Change one section at a time, keeping the rest intact, so you can tell which change did the work.

Related prompts

All productivity