Goal
Score a single support conversation fairly and consistently, then give the agent feedback they can use on their next ticket.
Inputs
- Conversation: [paste the full ticket or chat, with personal details removed]
- Company policies that applied: [refund rules, response time targets, escalation rules]
- Agent experience level: [new, under six months, experienced]
- Brand voice: [friendly, formal, concise]
Scoring rubric
Score each criterion from 0 to 4 and apply the weight shown.
| Criterion | Weight | | Understood the real issue | 25 | | Accurate and complete answer | 25 | | Followed policy correctly | 15 | | Tone and empathy | 15 | | Clarity and length | 10 | | Clear next step and ownership | 10 |
Output format
- Scorecard table: Criterion, Score, Weighted points, Evidence (a short quote from the conversation)
- Total out of 100, and a band: 90 and above Excellent, 75 to 89 Good, 60 to 74 Needs work, below 60 Coaching required
- Auto-fail check: yes or no, for wrong information about money, a privacy breach, or rudeness
- Two strengths and two coaching points, each tied to a quoted line
- Rewritten final reply, under 140 words, showing the improvements
Check before answering
- Every score has a quoted line as evidence; no score rests on a general impression.
- Weighted points equal score divided by 4, multiplied by the weight, and the total is added correctly.
- An auto-fail sets the band to "Coaching required" whatever the total.
- Coaching points describe actions, not personality.
- The rewritten reply uses only facts and remedies available to the agent at the time.






