Peer review report for a journal manuscript with major and minor comments
Helps a reviewer write a fair, specific peer review: a summary of the paper, the main strengths, major issues with the methods or claims, minor issues, and a recommendation to the editor, each comment tied to a section and line. Use it when reviewing for a journal or conference for the first time, or when a review keeps coming out vague.
The output this prompt produced, unedited.
The prompt
What to give
Journal or conference and its review criteria: [paste, or unknown]
Manuscript title, abstract and the sections you want checked: [paste]
Your own notes while reading: [paste, in any order]
Your field and how close it is to the paper: [e.g. same field, adjacent field]
Check the manuscript for each of these
The research question is stated and matters to the field.
The design fits the question, and the sample is described and large enough for the claims.
Methods are described well enough for someone to repeat the study.
Statistics suit the data, and effect sizes and uncertainty are reported, not only p values.
Results answer the question and match the tables and figures.
Claims in the discussion do not go further than the results.
Limitations are stated honestly.
References are current and include key opposing work.
Ethics approval, consent and data availability are stated where needed.
Figures and tables are readable and labelled.
Output format
Summary of the paper in four sentences, in neutral words, to show it was understood.
Main strengths: two to four points.
Major comments, numbered, each with the section or line, the problem, why it matters and what would fix it.
Minor comments, numbered, same shape, kept short.
Confidential comments to the editor, if any.
Recommendation: accept, minor revision, major revision or reject, with the reason in two sentences.
Guardrails
Courteous and specific; critique the work, never the authors.
Do not ask for citations to your own work unless they are essential, and say why.
Mark any point outside your expertise as such.
peer review reporthow to review a manuscriptjournal reviewer commentsmajor and minor revisionsacademic peer reviewreviewer template
How to run this
Copy the prompt and paste it into Gemini, then set the aspect ratio to 3:4. No reference photo is needed for this one.
The prompt is written in Markdown with each part under its own heading, which is what the copy action hands over. Change one section at a time, keeping the rest intact, so you can tell which change did the work.