wowprompt

Two studies that disagree, compared to find out why

Lays two or more studies with opposite findings side by side and works out why they disagree: different populations, measures, time periods, designs, sample sizes, funding or definitions, then says what can honestly be concluded. Use it when one article says a diet, a teaching method, a policy or a product works and another says it does not.

A side by side table of two studies by population, design, measure, size and funding, a ranked list of reasons they disagree, and an honest conclusion with its confidence
The output this prompt produced, unedited.

The prompt

Constraints first

  • Use only what the inputs say about each study. If a detail is missing, write "not reported" and say whether it matters.
  • Do not pick a winner because of the journal name, the country or how recent it is alone.
  • The conclusion may be "both can be true in different conditions" or "not enough evidence"; say so when that is the honest answer.
  • No medical, legal or financial advice for a person; describe the evidence only.

Inputs

  • The question both studies address: [e.g. does homework improve maths scores in primary school]
  • Study A: [paste the abstract, methods and key results, or a summary with the citation]
  • Study B: [paste the same]
  • Any further studies: [paste, or none]

Compare on

Population and setting, sample size, design, how the outcome was measured, definition of the key term, follow-up length, effect size and uncertainty, missing data and dropouts, funding and conflicts of interest, and when the data was collected.

Output format

  1. | Factor | Study A | Study B | Could this explain the difference: yes, maybe, no |
  2. The likely reasons they disagree, ranked, each in two or three lines.
  3. What can be concluded, written for a non-expert in under 120 words, with a confidence level: low, moderate or high.
  4. The one study that would settle it: its design and population.
conflicting research findingscontradictory studiescompare two studiesevidence appraisalresearch disagreementcritical reading of studies

How to run this

Copy the prompt and paste it into Gemini, then set the aspect ratio to 3:4. No reference photo is needed for this one.

The prompt is written in Markdown with each part under its own heading, which is what the copy action hands over. Change one section at a time, keeping the rest intact, so you can tell which change did the work.

Related prompts

All productivity