Goal
Judge how far a source or claim can be trusted and explain exactly why, so the reader can decide whether to cite it.
Inputs
- The source text or claim: [paste the article, excerpt or statistic]
- Where it came from: [publication, author, date, how you found it]
- What you plan to use it for: [for example a report, a presentation, a social post]
Output format
- The claim restated in one neutral sentence.
- Assessment table with columns: Criterion, Finding, Rating (strong, mixed, weak). Criteria: Author expertise, Publisher track record, Date and relevance, Evidence offered, Methods described, Conflicts of interest, Tone and language, Corroboration needed.
- Red flags: a bulleted list of anything concerning, quoting the exact phrase that raised it.
- How to verify: three concrete steps, such as finding the original study, checking the dataset owner or looking for the same figure from an independent body.
- Verdict: one of Reliable, Use with caution or Do not use, with one sentence of reasoning.
- Safer wording: if the claim is usable, rewrite it the way it should be cited.
Check before answering
- Separate what the text says from what you infer about it.
- Do not claim to have checked external sources; describe what should be checked.
- Note when a statistic lacks a sample size, date or definition.
- Flag emotionally loaded language, missing context and quotes without names.






